• AMZ AUTOMATOR Review Unearth the Ultimate Free Traffic Secret and Amazon Commissions!

    Welcome to my AMZ AUTOMATOR Review…

    Earning commissions through Amazon and promoting products has always been the most important strategy. However, there is a better and more efficient way that goes beyond the traditional approach.

    Imagine: Choosing a video style to showcase your products can dramatically up your game, attract more customers, and improve conversion rates. It is high time to change gears and adopt a new and improved method.

    Read More:
    https://dilip-review.com/amz-automator-review/

    #HowtoMakeMoneywithAMZAUTOMATOR
    #AMZAUTOMATORbyGlynnKosky
    #MakeMoneywithAMZAUTOMATOR
    #HowDoesAMZAUTOMATORWork
    #AMZAUTOMATORHonestReview
    #AMZAUTOMATORScamorLegit
    #HowtoBuyAMZAUTOMATOR
    #AMZAUTOMATORLiveDemo
    #AMZAUTOMATORDownload
    #AMZAUTOMATORUpgrades
    #AMZAUTOMATORSoftware
    #AMZAUTOMATORBonuses
    #AMZAUTOMATORReviews
    #AMZAUTOMATORPreview
    #AMZAUTOMATORUpsells
    #AMZAUTOMATORReview
    #AMZAUTOMATORBonus
    #AMZAUTOMATORDemo
    #AMZAUTOMATORScam
    #AMZAUTOMATORLegit
    #AMZAUTOMATOROTO
    #AMZAUTOMATORApp
    AMZ AUTOMATOR Review ๐Ÿ”ฅ Unearth the Ultimate Free Traffic Secret and Amazon Commissions! Welcome to my AMZ AUTOMATOR Review… Earning commissions through Amazon and promoting products has always been the most important strategy. However, there is a better and more efficient way that goes beyond the traditional approach. Imagine: Choosing a video style to showcase your products can dramatically up your game, attract more customers, and improve conversion rates. It is high time to change gears and adopt a new and improved method. Read More: https://dilip-review.com/amz-automator-review/ #HowtoMakeMoneywithAMZAUTOMATOR #AMZAUTOMATORbyGlynnKosky #MakeMoneywithAMZAUTOMATOR #HowDoesAMZAUTOMATORWork #AMZAUTOMATORHonestReview #AMZAUTOMATORScamorLegit #HowtoBuyAMZAUTOMATOR #AMZAUTOMATORLiveDemo #AMZAUTOMATORDownload #AMZAUTOMATORUpgrades #AMZAUTOMATORSoftware #AMZAUTOMATORBonuses #AMZAUTOMATORReviews #AMZAUTOMATORPreview #AMZAUTOMATORUpsells #AMZAUTOMATORReview #AMZAUTOMATORBonus #AMZAUTOMATORDemo #AMZAUTOMATORScam #AMZAUTOMATORLegit #AMZAUTOMATOROTO #AMZAUTOMATORApp
    DILIP-REVIEW.COM
    AMZ AUTOMATOR Review ๐Ÿ”ฅ Unearth the Ultimate Free Traffic Secret and Amazon Commissions!
    AMZ AUTOMATOR Review - AMZ AUTOMATOR uses AI and ChatGPT caches to drive Amazon traffic. The system provides you with generated books that
    Like
    1
    0 Comments 0 Shares 2919 Views
  • Esty Ease 2024 Review
    Setup your own ETSY store and start earning PASSIVE income easy!

    A web-based tool called Esty Ease 2024 was created especially for Etsy sellers. It provides several features and an intuitive interface designed to make running an Etsy store easier. Sellers can effortlessly track orders, manage inventory, improve listings, examine performance indicators, and much more with Esty Ease 2024.


    Read More :
    https://dilip-review.com/esty-ease-2024-review/

    #HowtoMakeMoneywithEstyEase2024
    #EstyEase2024MeiiSapphire
    #MakeMoneywithEstyEase2024
    #HowDoesEstyEase2024Work
    #EstyEase2024HonestReview
    #EstyEase2024ScamorLegit
    #HowtoBuyEstyEase2024
    #EstyEase2024LiveDemo
    #EstyEase2024Download
    #EstyEase2024Upgrades
    #EstyEase2024Software
    #EstyEase2024Bonuses
    #EstyEase2024Reviews
    #EstyEase2024Preview
    #EstyEase2024Upsells
    #EstyEase2024Review
    #EstyEase2024Bonus
    #EstyEase2024Demo
    #EstyEase2024Scam
    #EstyEase2024Legit
    #EstyEase2024OTO
    #EstyEase2024App
    Esty Ease 2024 Review Setup your own ETSY store and start earning PASSIVE income easy! A web-based tool called Esty Ease 2024 was created especially for Etsy sellers. It provides several features and an intuitive interface designed to make running an Etsy store easier. Sellers can effortlessly track orders, manage inventory, improve listings, examine performance indicators, and much more with Esty Ease 2024. Read More : https://dilip-review.com/esty-ease-2024-review/ #HowtoMakeMoneywithEstyEase2024 #EstyEase2024MeiiSapphire #MakeMoneywithEstyEase2024 #HowDoesEstyEase2024Work #EstyEase2024HonestReview #EstyEase2024ScamorLegit #HowtoBuyEstyEase2024 #EstyEase2024LiveDemo #EstyEase2024Download #EstyEase2024Upgrades #EstyEase2024Software #EstyEase2024Bonuses #EstyEase2024Reviews #EstyEase2024Preview #EstyEase2024Upsells #EstyEase2024Review #EstyEase2024Bonus #EstyEase2024Demo #EstyEase2024Scam #EstyEase2024Legit #EstyEase2024OTO #EstyEase2024App
    DILIP-REVIEW.COM
    Esty Ease 2024 Review | Setup your own ETSY store and start earning PASSIVE income easy!
    Esty Ease 2024 Review - A web-based tool called Esty Ease 2024 was created especially for Etsy sellers. It provides a number of features and
    Like
    1
    0 Comments 0 Shares 3057 Views
  • Coursiify Review | Create Your First E-Learning Platform


    World’s First AI App That Uses “Machine Learning”
    To Build Us A Profitable Udemy-Like Business
    Then Drives 19,575 Clicks To It Daily
    Imagine if you could own Udemy.com With a push of a button…


    Read More --
    https://dilip-review.com/coursiify-review/


    #HowtoMakeMoneywithCoursiify
    #CoursiifybySeyiAdeleke
    #MakeMoneywithCoursiify
    #HowDoesCoursiifyWork
    #CoursiifyHonestReview
    #CoursiifyScamorLegit
    #HowtoBuyCoursiify
    #CoursiifyLiveDemo
    #CoursiifyDownload
    #CoursiifyUpgrades
    #CoursiifySoftware
    #CoursiifyBonuses
    #CoursiifyReviews
    #CoursiifyPreview
    #CoursiifyUpsells
    #CoursiifyReview
    #CoursiifyBonus
    #CoursiifyDemo
    #CoursiifyScam
    #CoursiifyLegit
    #CoursiifyOTO
    #CoursiifyApp
    Coursiify Review | Create Your First E-Learning Platform World’s First AI App That Uses “Machine Learning” To Build Us A Profitable Udemy-Like Business Then Drives 19,575 Clicks To It Daily Imagine if you could own Udemy.com With a push of a button… Read More -- https://dilip-review.com/coursiify-review/ #HowtoMakeMoneywithCoursiify #CoursiifybySeyiAdeleke #MakeMoneywithCoursiify #HowDoesCoursiifyWork #CoursiifyHonestReview #CoursiifyScamorLegit #HowtoBuyCoursiify #CoursiifyLiveDemo #CoursiifyDownload #CoursiifyUpgrades #CoursiifySoftware #CoursiifyBonuses #CoursiifyReviews #CoursiifyPreview #CoursiifyUpsells #CoursiifyReview #CoursiifyBonus #CoursiifyDemo #CoursiifyScam #CoursiifyLegit #CoursiifyOTO #CoursiifyApp
    DILIP-REVIEW.COM
    Coursiify Review | Create Your First E-Learning Platform
    Coursiify Review - Imagine possessing a magical technology that could quickly develop an entire e-learning website for you
    0 Comments 0 Shares 3821 Views
  • Explore limitless possibilities with our worldwide global offer! From New York to Tokyo,
    unlock opportunities and maximize your earnings on a global scale.
    Join now and embark on a journey to success without borders!
    #GlobalOffer #WorldwideSuccess
    Claim Now...... https://t.ly/xvLd6
    ๐ŸŒ Explore limitless possibilities with our worldwide global offer! ๐Ÿš€ From New York to Tokyo, unlock opportunities and maximize your earnings on a global scale. ๐Ÿ’ผ Join now and embark on a journey to success without borders! #GlobalOffer #WorldwideSuccess Claim Now...... https://t.ly/xvLd6
    T.LY
    Global Giveway
    Win McDonalds Samples Claim Now
    0 Comments 0 Shares 1056 Views
  • Create a perfect learning and development plan that showcases an overview of the development program, main objectives, program outcomes and what methods are used in the training and development program, using this fully editable one-page learning and development plan PowerPoint template. You can also use this PPT template to showcase how the learning and development program helps the employees to improve their skills.
    Watch Now: https://youtube.com/shorts/bBEMN920eiI
    Download Now: https://bit.ly/3WK2AfC
    #learninganddevelopment #onepage #presentation #PPT #powerpointtemplates #slides
    Create a perfect learning and development plan that showcases an overview of the development program, main objectives, program outcomes and what methods are used in the training and development program, using this fully editable one-page learning and development plan PowerPoint template. You can also use this PPT template to showcase how the learning and development program helps the employees to improve their skills. Watch Now: https://youtube.com/shorts/bBEMN920eiI Download Now: https://bit.ly/3WK2AfC #learninganddevelopment #onepage #presentation #PPT #powerpointtemplates #slides
    0 Comments 0 Shares 2666 Views
  • Description
    Pineal XT Review - (( BEWARE!! )) - Pineal XT Gold - Pineal XT Ingredients - Pineal XT Supplement
    REGGAETON XPRE
    Pineal XT Review - (( BEWARE!! )) - Pineal XT Gold - Pineal XT Ingredients - Pineal XT Supplement

    ๐Ž๐…๐…๐ˆ๐‚๐ˆ๐€๐‹: https://pxt.pinealxt.com/ds/presentation/index.php#aff=Vivek5555
    ๐Ž๐…๐…๐ˆ๐‚๐ˆ๐€๐‹: https://pxt.pinealxt.com/ds/presentation/index.php#aff=Vivek5555


    Pineal XT is an innovative supplement designed to stimulate and purify the pineal gland, aiming to enhance cognitive and mental abilities while also exploring spiritual well-being. Inspired by a purported secret formula once used by the CIA, it is said to aid in opening the "third eye" and fostering a deeper connection with the universe. Here's a breakdown of its key ingredients:
    Amla extract: Rich in antioxidants and phytonutrients, it protects against free radicals, supports brain regeneration, and improves skin quality.
    Iodine: Essential for serotonin and dopamine production, crucial neurotransmitters for brain function and mood regulation, aiding in learning ability and mood stabilization.
    Turmeric: Contains curcumin, a potent anti-inflammatory agent that reduces inflammation in the nervous system, leading to better nerve signaling and function.
    Schisandra chinensis powder: Known for its neuroprotective properties due to lignan polyphenols antioxidants, it aids in detoxifying neural connections and supporting brain cell health.
    Chaga Mushroom: An adaptogen that protects against neurological disorders, enhances memory and cognitive function, and reduces stress while calming the nervous system.
    Chlorella powder: Rich in magnesium, it boosts blood flow and oxygen supply to the brain, improving memory and slowing cognitive decline associated with aging.
    Burdock powder: Provides neuroprotective effects, enhances brain health and function, and aids in improving the mind-muscle connection during activities like yoga or meditation.

    Pineal XT is manufactured in an FDA-certified facility adhering to GMP regulations, ensuring safety and purity standards. It is claimed to be free of harmful ingredients, gluten, GMOs, toxins, and contaminants. While it promotes physical health, it also delves into the spiritual realm, aiming for a journey devoid of unwanted side effects.

    Pineal XT Review - (( BEWARE!! )) - Pineal XT Gold - Pineal XT Ingredients - Pineal XT Supplement

    ๐Ž๐…๐…๐ˆ๐‚๐ˆ๐€๐‹: https://pxt.pinealxt.com/ds/presentation/index.php#aff=Vivek5555
    ๐Ž๐…๐…๐ˆ๐‚๐ˆ๐€๐‹: https://pxt.pinealxt.com/ds/presentation/index.php#aff=Vivek5555


    Extra Tags: pinealxt,pineal xt,pineal xt reviews,pineal gland,pineal xt review,pinealxt review,pineal xt buy,pinealxt reviews,pineal xt pills,pineal xt supplement,pineal xt,pineal xt gold,formula,pineal xt legit,pineal xt works,pineal gland activation,pineal xt caps,pineal xt results,get pineal xt,pineal xt benefits,pineal xt order,pineal xt official website,pineal xt review 2024,what is pineal xt,pineal,pineal xt customer review,pineal xt where to buy,pineal xt 2024, pineal xt scam, pineal xt legit, pineal xt complaints, pineal xt ingredients,pineal xt pills, pineal xt capsules
    REGGAETON X

    Description Pineal XT Review - (( BEWARE!! )) - Pineal XT Gold - Pineal XT Ingredients - Pineal XT Supplement REGGAETON X๐Ÿ’ฏPRE Pineal XT Review - (( BEWARE!! )) - Pineal XT Gold - Pineal XT Ingredients - Pineal XT Supplement โœ…๐Ž๐…๐…๐ˆ๐‚๐ˆ๐€๐‹:๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡ https://pxt.pinealxt.com/ds/presentation/index.php#aff=Vivek5555 โœ…๐Ž๐…๐…๐ˆ๐‚๐ˆ๐€๐‹:๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡ https://pxt.pinealxt.com/ds/presentation/index.php#aff=Vivek5555 Pineal XT is an innovative supplement designed to stimulate and purify the pineal gland, aiming to enhance cognitive and mental abilities while also exploring spiritual well-being. Inspired by a purported secret formula once used by the CIA, it is said to aid in opening the "third eye" and fostering a deeper connection with the universe. Here's a breakdown of its key ingredients: Amla extract: Rich in antioxidants and phytonutrients, it protects against free radicals, supports brain regeneration, and improves skin quality. Iodine: Essential for serotonin and dopamine production, crucial neurotransmitters for brain function and mood regulation, aiding in learning ability and mood stabilization. Turmeric: Contains curcumin, a potent anti-inflammatory agent that reduces inflammation in the nervous system, leading to better nerve signaling and function. Schisandra chinensis powder: Known for its neuroprotective properties due to lignan polyphenols antioxidants, it aids in detoxifying neural connections and supporting brain cell health. Chaga Mushroom: An adaptogen that protects against neurological disorders, enhances memory and cognitive function, and reduces stress while calming the nervous system. Chlorella powder: Rich in magnesium, it boosts blood flow and oxygen supply to the brain, improving memory and slowing cognitive decline associated with aging. Burdock powder: Provides neuroprotective effects, enhances brain health and function, and aids in improving the mind-muscle connection during activities like yoga or meditation. Pineal XT is manufactured in an FDA-certified facility adhering to GMP regulations, ensuring safety and purity standards. It is claimed to be free of harmful ingredients, gluten, GMOs, toxins, and contaminants. While it promotes physical health, it also delves into the spiritual realm, aiming for a journey devoid of unwanted side effects. Pineal XT Review - (( BEWARE!! )) - Pineal XT Gold - Pineal XT Ingredients - Pineal XT Supplement โœ…๐Ž๐…๐…๐ˆ๐‚๐ˆ๐€๐‹:๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡ https://pxt.pinealxt.com/ds/presentation/index.php#aff=Vivek5555 โœ…๐Ž๐…๐…๐ˆ๐‚๐ˆ๐€๐‹:๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡ https://pxt.pinealxt.com/ds/presentation/index.php#aff=Vivek5555 Extra Tags: pinealxt,pineal xt,pineal xt reviews,pineal gland,pineal xt review,pinealxt review,pineal xt buy,pinealxt reviews,pineal xt pills,pineal xt supplement,pineal xt,pineal xt gold,formula,pineal xt legit,pineal xt works,pineal gland activation,pineal xt caps,pineal xt results,get pineal xt,pineal xt benefits,pineal xt order,pineal xt official website,pineal xt review 2024,what is pineal xt,pineal,pineal xt customer review,pineal xt where to buy,pineal xt 2024, pineal xt scam, pineal xt legit, pineal xt complaints, pineal xt ingredients,pineal xt pills, pineal xt capsules REGGAETON X๐Ÿ’ฏ
    0 Comments 0 Shares 7460 Views
  • Jambo Super App (Jambo Phone)

    Jambo: Gaming, watching videos, exploring social media and earning rewards

    Subscription path
    https://jambowallet.app.link/PS94g8Hh5Ib

    Current features of the Jambo Super app
    JamboPlay - An ecosystem gaming partner directory that helps you complete your quest by applying what you learned from JamboAcademy!

    JamboWallet - A JamboEarn wallet with the JamboScore system that helps users get more rewards through the app and early access to their upcoming JamboColor smartphones!
    Jambo Super App (Jambo Phone) Jambo: Gaming, watching videos, exploring social media and earning rewards Subscription path https://jambowallet.app.link/PS94g8Hh5Ib Current features of the Jambo Super app ๐ŸŽฎ JamboPlay - An ecosystem gaming partner directory that helps you complete your quest by applying what you learned from JamboAcademy! ๐Ÿ‘ JamboWallet - A JamboEarn wallet with the JamboScore system that helps users get more rewards through the app and early access to their upcoming JamboColor smartphones!
    JAMBOWALLET.APP.LINK
    Jambo | Building the Web3 Mobile Infrastructure for Emerging Markets
    Jambo is a leading innovator dedicated to connecting emerging markets with the digital world through user-friendly, affordable technology. With a focus on education and financial inclusion, Jambo is committed to unlocking the potential of technology in emerging markets with the Web3 Mobile Infrastructure for Emerging Markets
    0 Comments 0 Shares 3681 Views
  • Explore this fully customizable money dividends icon PowerPoint template to give an overview of money distribution and showcase the key stats on how much the company distribute its earnings among the investors, share of stock or cash. Download Now: https://bit.ly/3s2nH1u
    #dividends #dividendstocks #moneymanagement #powerpointpresentation #ppt
    Explore this fully customizable money dividends icon PowerPoint template to give an overview of money distribution and showcase the key stats on how much the company distribute its earnings among the investors, share of stock or cash. Download Now: https://bit.ly/3s2nH1u #dividends #dividendstocks #moneymanagement #powerpointpresentation #ppt
    BIT.LY
    Money Dividends Icon PowerPoint Template | PPT Templates
    Features: Widescreen 16:9 You can change the color of the icons You can change the size, color and orientation of the shape Replace the text as per your need Replace an image as per your requirement
    0 Comments 0 Shares 2464 Views
  • Coinz Review | How Does Coinz Work

    Are you interested in learning more about cryptocurrencies but need to be put off by how complicated mining and trading are? Presenting Coinz, the hassle-free way to get free Ethereum and Bitcoin. We’ll examine what makes Coinz unique in this review and how it may help novice and seasoned cryptocurrency users.


    Read Full Review >>
    https://dilip-review.com/coinz-review/


    #HowtoMakeMoneywithCoinz
    #CoinzbySeyiAdeleke
    #MakeMoneywithCoinz
    #HowDoesCoinzWork
    #CoinzHonestReview
    #CoinzScamorLegit
    #HowtoBuyCoinz
    #CoinzLiveDemo
    #CoinzDownload
    #CoinzUpgrades
    #CoinzSoftware
    #CoinzBonuses
    #CoinzReviews
    #CoinzPreview
    #CoinzUpsells
    #CoinzReview
    #CoinzBonus
    #CoinzDemo
    #CoinzScam
    #CoinzLegit
    #CoinzOTO
    #CoinzApp
    Coinz Review | How Does Coinz Work Are you interested in learning more about cryptocurrencies but need to be put off by how complicated mining and trading are? Presenting Coinz, the hassle-free way to get free Ethereum and Bitcoin. We’ll examine what makes Coinz unique in this review and how it may help novice and seasoned cryptocurrency users. Read Full Review >> https://dilip-review.com/coinz-review/ #HowtoMakeMoneywithCoinz #CoinzbySeyiAdeleke #MakeMoneywithCoinz #HowDoesCoinzWork #CoinzHonestReview #CoinzScamorLegit #HowtoBuyCoinz #CoinzLiveDemo #CoinzDownload #CoinzUpgrades #CoinzSoftware #CoinzBonuses #CoinzReviews #CoinzPreview #CoinzUpsells #CoinzReview #CoinzBonus #CoinzDemo #CoinzScam #CoinzLegit #CoinzOTO #CoinzApp
    DILIP-REVIEW.COM
    Coinz Review | Enjoy FREE Bitcoin On Autopilot - Dilip-Review
    Coinz Review - Are you interested in learning more about cryptocurrencies but need to be put off by how complicated mining and trading are?
    Love
    1
    0 Comments 0 Shares 9077 Views
  • Meta Refuses to Answer Questions on Gaza Censorship, Say Sens. Warren and Sanders
    Sam BiddleMarch 26 2024, 8:00 a.m.
    WASHINGTON, DC - MARCH 03: Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) questions U.S. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell as he testifies at a Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee hearing on the Fed's "Semiannual Monetary Policy Report to the Congress," on Capitol Hill on March 3, 2022 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Tom Williams-Pool/Getty Images)
    Citing the company’s “failure to provide answers to important questions,” Sens. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., are pressing Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram, to respond to reports of disproportionate censorship around the Israeli war on Gaza.

    “Meta insists that there’s been no discrimination against Palestinian-related content on their platforms, but at the same time, is refusing to provide us with any evidence or data to support that claim,” Warren told The Intercept. “If its ad-hoc changes and removal of millions of posts didn’t discriminate against Palestinian-related content, then what’s Meta hiding?”

    In a letter to Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg sent last December, first reported by The Intercept, Warren presented the company with dozens of specific questions about the company’s Gaza-related content moderation efforts. Warren asked about the exact numbers of posts about the war, broken down by Hebrew or Arabic, that have been deleted or otherwise suppressed.

    The letter was written following widespread reporting in The Intercept and other outlets that detailed how posts on Meta platforms that are sympathetic to Palestinians, or merely depicting the destruction in Gaza, are routinely removed or hidden without explanation.

    A month later, Meta replied to Warren’s office with a six-page letter, obtained by The Intercept, that provided an overview of its moderation response to the war but little in the way of specifics or new information.

    Most Read

    “Meta’s lack of investment to safeguard its users significantly exacerbates the political situation in Palestine and perpetuates tech harms on fundamental rights in Palestine and other global majority countries, all while evading meaningful legal accountability,” Mona Shtaya, nonresident fellow at the Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy, told The Intercept. “The time has come for Meta, among other tech giants, to publicly disclose detailed measures and investments aimed at safeguarding individuals amidst the ongoing genocide, and to be more responsive to experts and civil society.”

    Meta’s reply disclosed some censorship: “In the nine days following October 7, we removed or marked as disturbing more than 2,200,000 pieces of content in Hebrew and Arabic for violating our policies.” The company declined, however, to provide a breakdown of deletions by language or market, making it impossible to tell whether that figure reflects discriminatory moderation practices.

    Much of Meta’s letter is a rehash of an update it provided through its public relations portal at the war’s onset, some of it verbatim.

    Now, a second letter from Warren to Meta, joined this time by Sanders, says this isn’t enough. “Meta’s response, dated January 29, 2024, did not provide any of the requested information necessary to understand Meta’s treatment of Arabic language or Palestine-related content versus other forms of content,” the senators wrote.

    Both senators are asking Meta to again answer Warren’s specific questions about the extent to which Arabic and Hebrew posts about the war have been treated differently, how often censored posts are reinstated, Meta’s use of automated machine learning-based censorship tools, and more.

    Accusations of systemic moderation bias against Palestinians have been borne out by research from rights groups.

    “Since October 7, Human Rights Watch has documented over 1,000 cases of unjustified takedowns and other suppression of content on Instagram and Facebook related to Palestine and Palestinians, including about human rights abuses,” Human Rights Watch said in a late December report. “The censorship of content related to Palestine on Instagram and Facebook is systemic, global, and a product of the company’s failure to meet its human rights due diligence responsibilities.”


    Related

    Meta Considering Increased Censorship of the Word “Zionist”

    A February report by AccessNow said Meta “suspended or restricted the accounts of Palestinian journalists and activists both in and outside of Gaza, and arbitrarily deleted a considerable amount of content, including documentation of atrocities and human rights abuses.”

    A third-party audit commissioned by Meta itself previously concluded it had given the short shrift to Palestinian rights during a May 2021 flare-up of violence between Israel and Hamas, the militant group that controls the Gaza Strip. “Meta’s actions in May 2021 appear to have had an adverse human rights impact … on the rights of Palestinian users to freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, political participation, and non-discrimination, and therefore on the ability of Palestinians to share information and insights about their experiences as they occurred,” said the auditor’s report.

    In response to this audit, Meta pledged an array of reforms, which free expression and digital rights advocates say have yet to produce a material improvement.

    In its December report, Human Rights Watch noted, “More than two years after committing to publishing data around government requests for taking down content that is not necessarily illegal, Meta has failed to increase transparency in this area.”

    Update: March 26, 2024, 1:11 p.m. ET
    This story has been updated to include a statement received after publication from Mona Shtaya, a nonresident fellow at the Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy.

    https://theintercept.com/2024/03/26/meta-gaza-censorship-warren-sanders/
    Meta Refuses to Answer Questions on Gaza Censorship, Say Sens. Warren and Sanders Sam BiddleMarch 26 2024, 8:00 a.m. WASHINGTON, DC - MARCH 03: Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) questions U.S. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell as he testifies at a Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee hearing on the Fed's "Semiannual Monetary Policy Report to the Congress," on Capitol Hill on March 3, 2022 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Tom Williams-Pool/Getty Images) Citing the company’s “failure to provide answers to important questions,” Sens. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., are pressing Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram, to respond to reports of disproportionate censorship around the Israeli war on Gaza. “Meta insists that there’s been no discrimination against Palestinian-related content on their platforms, but at the same time, is refusing to provide us with any evidence or data to support that claim,” Warren told The Intercept. “If its ad-hoc changes and removal of millions of posts didn’t discriminate against Palestinian-related content, then what’s Meta hiding?” In a letter to Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg sent last December, first reported by The Intercept, Warren presented the company with dozens of specific questions about the company’s Gaza-related content moderation efforts. Warren asked about the exact numbers of posts about the war, broken down by Hebrew or Arabic, that have been deleted or otherwise suppressed. The letter was written following widespread reporting in The Intercept and other outlets that detailed how posts on Meta platforms that are sympathetic to Palestinians, or merely depicting the destruction in Gaza, are routinely removed or hidden without explanation. A month later, Meta replied to Warren’s office with a six-page letter, obtained by The Intercept, that provided an overview of its moderation response to the war but little in the way of specifics or new information. Most Read “Meta’s lack of investment to safeguard its users significantly exacerbates the political situation in Palestine and perpetuates tech harms on fundamental rights in Palestine and other global majority countries, all while evading meaningful legal accountability,” Mona Shtaya, nonresident fellow at the Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy, told The Intercept. “The time has come for Meta, among other tech giants, to publicly disclose detailed measures and investments aimed at safeguarding individuals amidst the ongoing genocide, and to be more responsive to experts and civil society.” Meta’s reply disclosed some censorship: “In the nine days following October 7, we removed or marked as disturbing more than 2,200,000 pieces of content in Hebrew and Arabic for violating our policies.” The company declined, however, to provide a breakdown of deletions by language or market, making it impossible to tell whether that figure reflects discriminatory moderation practices. Much of Meta’s letter is a rehash of an update it provided through its public relations portal at the war’s onset, some of it verbatim. Now, a second letter from Warren to Meta, joined this time by Sanders, says this isn’t enough. “Meta’s response, dated January 29, 2024, did not provide any of the requested information necessary to understand Meta’s treatment of Arabic language or Palestine-related content versus other forms of content,” the senators wrote. Both senators are asking Meta to again answer Warren’s specific questions about the extent to which Arabic and Hebrew posts about the war have been treated differently, how often censored posts are reinstated, Meta’s use of automated machine learning-based censorship tools, and more. Accusations of systemic moderation bias against Palestinians have been borne out by research from rights groups. “Since October 7, Human Rights Watch has documented over 1,000 cases of unjustified takedowns and other suppression of content on Instagram and Facebook related to Palestine and Palestinians, including about human rights abuses,” Human Rights Watch said in a late December report. “The censorship of content related to Palestine on Instagram and Facebook is systemic, global, and a product of the company’s failure to meet its human rights due diligence responsibilities.” Related Meta Considering Increased Censorship of the Word “Zionist” A February report by AccessNow said Meta “suspended or restricted the accounts of Palestinian journalists and activists both in and outside of Gaza, and arbitrarily deleted a considerable amount of content, including documentation of atrocities and human rights abuses.” A third-party audit commissioned by Meta itself previously concluded it had given the short shrift to Palestinian rights during a May 2021 flare-up of violence between Israel and Hamas, the militant group that controls the Gaza Strip. “Meta’s actions in May 2021 appear to have had an adverse human rights impact … on the rights of Palestinian users to freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, political participation, and non-discrimination, and therefore on the ability of Palestinians to share information and insights about their experiences as they occurred,” said the auditor’s report. In response to this audit, Meta pledged an array of reforms, which free expression and digital rights advocates say have yet to produce a material improvement. In its December report, Human Rights Watch noted, “More than two years after committing to publishing data around government requests for taking down content that is not necessarily illegal, Meta has failed to increase transparency in this area.” Update: March 26, 2024, 1:11 p.m. ET This story has been updated to include a statement received after publication from Mona Shtaya, a nonresident fellow at the Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy. https://theintercept.com/2024/03/26/meta-gaza-censorship-warren-sanders/
    THEINTERCEPT.COM
    Meta Refuses to Answer Questions on Gaza Censorship, Say Sens. Warren and Sanders
    Facebook and Instagram’s parent company Meta dodged questions from Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders about censorship of posts about Gaza.
    0 Comments 0 Shares 12889 Views
  • The Silent Shame of Health Institutions
    J.R. Bruning
    For how much longer will health policy ignore multimorbidity, that looming, giant elephant in the room, that propagates and amplifies suffering? For how much longer will the ‘trend’ of increasing diagnoses of multiple health conditions, at younger and younger ages be rendered down by government agencies to better and more efficient services, screening modalities, and drug choices?

    Multimorbidity, the presence of many chronic conditions, is the silent shame of health policy.

    All too often chronic conditions overlap and accumulate. From cancer, to diabetes, to digestive system diseases, to high blood pressure, to skin conditions in cascades of suffering. Heartbreakingly, these conditions commonly overlap with mental illnesses or disorders. It’s increasingly common for people to be diagnosed with multiple mental conditions, such as having anxiety and depression, or anxiety and schizophrenia.

    Calls for equity tend to revolve around medical treatment, even as absurdities and injustices accrue.

    Multimorbidity occurs a decade earlier in socioeconomically deprived communities. Doctors are diagnosing multimorbidity at younger and younger ages.

    Treatment regimens for people with multiple conditions necessarily entail a polypharmacy approach – the prescribing of multiple medications. One condition may require multiple medications. Thus, with multimorbidity comes increased risk of adverse outcomes and polyiatrogenesis – ‘medical harm caused by medical treatments on multiple fronts simultaneously and in conjunction with one another.’

    Side effects, whether short-term or patients’ concerns about long-term harm, are the main reason for non-adherence to prescribed medications.

    So ‘equity’ which only implies drug treatment doesn’t involve equity at all.

    Poor diets may be foundational to the Western world’s health crisis. But are governments considering this?

    The antinomies are piling up.

    We are amid a global epidemic of metabolic syndrome. Insulin resistance, obesity, elevated triglyceride levels and low levels of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol, and elevated blood pressure haunt the people queuing up to see doctors.

    Research, from individual cases to clinical trials, consistently show that diets containing high levels of ultra-processed foods and carbohydrates amplify inflammation, oxidative stress, and insulin resistance. What researchers and scientists are also identifying, at the cellular level, in clinical and medical practice, and at the global level – is that insulin resistance, inflammation, oxidative stress, and nutrient deficiencies from poor diets not only drive metabolic illness, but mental illnesses, compounding suffering.

    There is also ample evidence that the metabolic and mental health epidemic that is driving years lost due to disease, reducing productivity, and creating mayhem in personal lives – may be preventable and reversible.

    Doctors generally recognise that poor diets are a problem. Ultra-processed foods are strongly associated with adult and childhood ill health. Ultra-processed foods are

    ‘formulations of ingredients, mostly of exclusive industrial use, typically created by series of industrial techniques and processes (hence ‘ultra-processed’).’

    In the USA young people under age 19 consume on average 67% of their diet, while adults consume around 60% of their diet in ultra-processed food. Ultra-processed food contributes 60% of UK children’s calories; 42% of Australian children’s calories and over half the dietary calories for children and adolescents in Canada. In New Zealand in 2009-2010, ultra-processed foods contributed to the 45% (12 months), 42% (24 months), and 51% (60 months) of energy intake to the diets of children.

    All too frequently, doctors are diagnosing both metabolic and mental illnesses.

    What may be predictable is that a person is likely to develop insulin resistance, inflammation, oxidative stress, and nutrient deficiencies from chronic exposure to ultra-processed food. How this will manifest in a disease or syndrome condition is reflective of a human equivalent of quantum entanglement.

    Cascades, feedback loops, and other interdependencies often leave doctors and patients bouncing from one condition to another, and managing medicine side effects and drug-drug relationships as they go.

    In New Zealand it is more common to have multiple conditions than a single condition. The costs of having two NCDs simultaneously is typically superadditive and ‘more so for younger adults.’

    This information is outside the ‘work programme’ of the top echelons in the Ministry of Health:

    Official Information Act (OIA) requests confirm that the Ministries’ Directors General who are responsible for setting policy and long-term strategy aren’t considering these issues. The problem of multimorbidity and the overlapping, entangled relationship with ultra-processed food is outside of the scope of the work programme of the top directorates in our health agency.

    New Zealand’s Ministry of Health’s top deputy directors general might be earning a quarter of a million dollars each, but they are ignorant of the relationship of dietary nutrition and mental health. Nor are they seemingly aware of the extent of multimorbidity and the overlap between metabolic and mental illnesses.

    Neither the Public Health Agency Deputy Director-General – Dr Andrew Old, nor the Deputy Director-General Evidence, Research and Innovation, Dean Rutherford, nor the Deputy Director-General of Strategy Policy and Legislation, Maree Roberts, nor the Clinical, Community and Mental Health Deputy Director-General Robyn Shearer have been briefed on these relationships.

    If they’re not being briefed, policy won’t be developed to address dietary nutrition. Diet will be lower-order.

    The OIA request revealed that New Zealand’s Ministry of Health ‘does not widely use the metabolic syndrome classification.’ When I asked ‘How do you classify, or what term do you use to classify the cluster of symptoms characterised by central obesity, dyslipidemia, hypertension, and insulin resistance?’, they responded:

    ‘The conditions referred to are considered either on their own or as part of a broader cardiovascular disease risk calculation.’

    This is interesting. What if governments should be calculating insulin resistance first, in order to then calculate a broader cardiovascular risk? What if insulin resistance, inflammation, and oxidative stress are appearing at younger and younger ages, and ultra-processed food is the major driver?

    Pre-diabetes and Type 2 diabetes are driven by too much blood glucose. Type 1 diabetics can’t make insulin, while Type 2 diabetics can’t make enough to compensate for their dietary intake of carbohydrates. One of insulin’s (many) jobs is to tuck away that blood glucose into cells (as fat) but when there are too many dietary carbohydrates pumping up blood glucose, the body can’t keep up. New Zealand practitioners use the HbA1c blood test, which measures the average blood glucose level over the past 2-3 months. In New Zealand, doctors diagnose pre-diabetes if HbA1c levels are 41-49 nmol/mol, and diabetes at levels of 50 nmol/mol and above.

    Type 2 diabetes management guidelines recommend that sugar intake should be reduced, while people should aim for consistent carbohydrates across the day. The New Zealand government does not recommend paleo or low-carbohydrate diets.

    If you have diabetes you are twice as likely to have heart disease or a stroke, and at a younger age. Prediabetes, which apparently 20% of Kiwis have, is also high-risk due to, as the Ministry of Health states: ‘increased risk of macrovascular complications and early death.’

    The question might become – should we be looking at insulin levels, to more sensitively gauge risk at an early stage?

    Without more sensitive screens at younger ages these opportunities to repivot to avoid chronic disease are likely to be missed. Currently, Ministry of Health policies are unlikely to justify the funding of tests for insulin resistance by using three simple blood tests: fasting insulin, fasting lipids (cholesterol and triglycerides), and fasting glucose – to estimate where children, young people, and adults stand on the insulin resistance spectrum when other diagnoses pop up.

    Yet insulin plays a powerful role in brain health.

    Insulin supports neurotransmitter function and brain energy, directly impacting mood and behaviours. Insulin resistance might arrive before mental illness. Harvard-based psychiatrist Chris Palmer recounts in the book Brain Energy, a large 15,000-participant study of young people from age 0-24:

    ‘Children who had persistently high insulin levels (a sign of insulin resistance) beginning at age nine were five times more likely to be at risk for psychosis, meaning they were showing at least some worrisome signs, and they were three times for likely to already be diagnosed with bipolar disorder or schizophrenia by the time they turned twenty-four. This study clearly demonstrated that insulin resistance comes first, then psychosis.’

    Psychiatrist Georgia Ede suggests that high blood glucose and high insulin levels act like a ‘deadly one-two punch’ for the brain, triggering waves of inflammation and oxidative stress. The blood-brain barrier becomes increasingly resistant to chronic high insulin levels. Even though the body might have higher blood insulin, the same may not be true for the brain. As Ede maintains, ‘cells deprived of adequate insulin ‘sputter and struggle to maintain normal operations.’

    Looking at the relationship between brain health and high blood glucose and high insulin simply might not be on the programme for strategists looking at long-term planning.

    Nor are Directors General in a position to assess the role of food addiction. Ultra-processed food has addictive qualities designed into the product formulations. Food addiction is increasingly recognised as pervasive and difficult to manage as any substance addiction.

    But how many children and young people have insulin resistance and are showing markers for inflammation and oxidative stress – in the body and in the brain? To what extent do young people have both insulin resistance and depression resistance or ADHD or bipolar disorder?

    This kind of thinking is completely outside the work programme. But insulin levels, inflammation, and oxidative stress may not only be driving chronic illness – but driving the global mental health tsunami.

    Metabolic disorders are involved in complex pathways and feedback loops across body systems, and doctors learn this at medical school. Patterns and relationships between hormones, the brain, the gastrointestinal system, kidneys, and liver; as well as problems with joints and bone health, autoimmunity, nerves, and sensory conditions evolve from and revolve around metabolic health.

    Nutrition and diet are downplayed in medical school. What doctors don’t learn so much – the cognitive dissonance that they must accept throughout their training – is that metabolic health is commonly (except for some instances) shaped by the quality of dietary nutrition. The aetiology of a given condition can be very different, while the evidence that common chronic and mental illnesses are accompanied by oxidative stress, inflammation, and insulin resistance are primarily driven by diet – is growing stronger and stronger.

    But without recognising the overlapping relationships, policy to support healthy diets will remain limp.

    What we witness are notions of equity that support pharmaceutical delivery – not health delivery.

    What also inevitably happens is that ‘equity’ focuses on medical treatment. When the Ministry of Health prefers to atomise the different conditions or associate them with heart disease – they become single conditions to treat with single drugs. They’re lots of small problems, not one big problem, and insulin resistance is downplayed.

    But just as insulin resistance, inflammation, and oxidative stress send cascading impacts across body systems, systemic ignorance sends cascading effects across government departments tasked with ‘improving, promoting, and protecting health.’

    It’s an injustice. The literature solidly points to lower socio-economic status driving much poorer diets and increased exposures to ultra-processed food, but the treatments exclusively involve drugs and therapy.

    Briefings to Incoming Ministers with the election of new Governments show how ignorance cascades across responsible authorities.

    Health New Zealand, Te Whatu Ora’s November 2023 Briefing to the new government outlined the agency’s obligations. However, the ‘health’ targets are medical, and the agency’s focus is on infrastructure, staff, and servicing. The promotion of health, and health equity, which can only be addressed by addressing the determinants of health, is not addressed.

    The Mฤori Health Authority and Health New Zealand Joint Briefing to the Incoming Minister for Mental Health does not address the role of diet and nutrition as a driver of mental illness and disorder in New Zealand. The issue of multimorbidity, the related problem of commensurate metabolic illness, and diet as a driver is outside scope. When the Briefing states that it is important to address the ‘social, cultural, environmental and economic determinants of mental health,’ without any sound policy footing, real movement to address diet will not happen, or will only happen ad hoc.

    The Mental Health and Wellbeing Commission, Te Hiringa Mahara’s November 2023 Briefing to Incoming Ministers that went to the Ministers for Health and Mental Health might use the term ‘well-being’ over 120 times – but was silent on the related and overlapping drivers of mental illness which include metabolic or multimorbidity, nutrition, or diet.

    Five years earlier, He Ara Ora, New Zealand’s 2018 Mental Health and Addiction enquiry had recognised that tฤngata whaiora, people seeking wellness, or service users, also tend to have multiple health conditions. The enquiry recommended that a whole of government approach to well-being, prevention, and social determinants was required. Vague nods were made to diet and nutrition, but this was not sufficiently emphasised as to be a priority.

    He Ara Ora was followed by 2020 Long-term pathway to mental well-being viewed nutrition as being one of a range of factors. No policy framework strategically prioritised diet, nutrition, and healthy food. No governmental obligation or commitment was built into policy to improve access to healthy food or nutrition education.

    Understanding the science, the relationships, and the drivers of the global epidemic, is ‘outside the work programmes’ of New Zealand’s Ministry of Health and outside the scope of all the related authorities. There is an extraordinary amount of data in the scientific literature, so many case studies, cohort studies, and clinical trials. Popular books are being written, however government agencies remain ignorant.

    In the meantime, doctors must deal with the suffering in front of them without an adequate toolkit.

    Doctors and pharmacists are faced with a Hobson’s choice of managing multiple chronic conditions and complex drug cocktails, in patients at younger and younger ages. Ultimately, they are treating a patient whom they recognise will only become sicker, cost the health system more, and suffer more.

    Currently there is little support for New Zealand medical doctors (known as general practitioners, or GPs) in changing practices and recommendations to support non-pharmaceutical drug treatment approaches. Their medical education does not equip them to recognise the extent to which multiple co-existing conditions may be alleviated or reversed. Doctors are paid to prescribe, to inject, and to screen, not to ameliorate or reverse disease and lessen prescribing. The prescribing of nutrients is discouraged and as doctors do not have nutritional training, they hesitate to prescribe nutrients.

    Many do not want to risk going outside treatment guidelines. Recent surges in protocols and guidelines for medical doctors reduce flexibility and narrow treatment choices for doctors. If they were to be reported to the Medical Council of New Zealand, they would risk losing their medical license. They would then be unable to practice.

    Inevitably, without Ministry of Health leadership, medical doctors in New Zealand are unlikely to voluntarily prescribe non-drug modalities such as nutritional options to any meaningful extent, for fear of being reported.

    Yet some doctors are proactive, such as Dr Glen Davies in Taupo, New Zealand. Some doctors are in a better ‘place’ to work to alleviate and reverse long-term conditions. They may be later in their career, with 10-20 years of research into metabolism, dietary nutrition, and patient care, and motivated to guide a patient through a personal care regime which might alleviate or reverse a patient’s suffering.

    Barriers include resourcing. Doctors aren’t paid for reversing disease and taking patients off medications.

    Doctors witness daily the hopelessness felt by their patients in dealing with chronic conditions in their short 15-minute consultations, and the vigilance required for dealing with adverse drug effects. Drug non-compliance is associated with adverse effects suffered by patients. Yet without wrap-around support changing treatments, even if it has potential to alleviate multiple conditions, to reduce symptoms, lower prescribing and therefore lessen side effects, is just too uncertain.

    They saw what happened to disobedient doctors during Covid-19.

    Given such context, what are we to do?

    Have open public discussions about doctor-patient relationships and trust. Inform and overlay such conversations by drawing attention to the foundational Hippocratic Oath made by doctors, to first do no harm.

    Questions can be asked. If patients were to understand that diet may be an underlying driver of multiple conditions, and a change in diet and improvement in micronutrient status might alleviate suffering – would patients be more likely to change?

    Economically, if wrap-around services were provided in clinics to support dietary change, would less harm occur to patients from worsening conditions that accompany many diseases (such as Type 2 diabetes) and the ever-present problem of drug side-effects? Would education and wrap-around services in early childhood and youth delay or prevent the onset of multimorbid diagnoses?

    Is it more ethical to give young people a choice of treatment? Could doctors prescribe dietary changes and multinutrients and support change with wrap-around support when children and young people are first diagnosed with a mental health condition – from the clinic, to school, to after school? If that doesn’t work, then prescribe pharmaceutical drugs.

    Should children and young people be educated to appreciate the extent to which their consumption of ultra-processed food likely drives their metabolic and mental health conditions? Not just in a blithe ‘eat healthy’ fashion that patently avoids discussing addiction. Through deeper policy mechanisms, including cooking classes and nutritional biology by the implementation of nourishing, low-carbohydrate cooked school lunches.

    With officials uninformed, it’s easy to see why funding for Green Prescriptions that would support dietary changes have sputtered out. It’s easy to understand why neither the Ministry of Health nor Pharmac have proactively sourced multi-nutrient treatments that improve resilience to stress and trauma for low-income young people. Why there’s no discussion on a lower side-effect risk for multinutrient treatments. Why are there no policies in the education curriculum diving into the relationship between ultra-processed food and mental and physical health? It’s not in the work programme.

    There’s another surfacing dilemma.

    Currently, if doctors tell their patients that there is very good evidence that their disease or syndrome could be reversed, and this information is not held as factual information by New Zealand’s Ministry of Health – do doctors risk being accused of spreading misinformation?

    Government agencies have pivoted in the past 5 years to focus intensively on the problem of dis- and misinformation. New Zealand’s disinformation project states that

    Disinformation is false or modified information knowingly and deliberately shared to cause harm or achieve a broader aim.
    Misinformation is information that is false or misleading, though not created or shared with the direct intention of causing harm.
    Unfortunately, as we see, there is no division inside the Ministry of Health that reviews the latest evidence in the scientific literature, to ensure that policy decisions correctly reflect the latest evidence.

    There is no scientific agency outside the Ministry of Health that has flexibility and the capacity to undertake autonomous, long-term monitoring and research in nutrition, diet, and health. There is no independent, autonomous, public health research facility with sufficient long-term funding to translate dietary and nutritional evidence into policy, particularly if it contradicted current policy positions.

    Despite excellent research being undertaken, it is highly controlled, ad hoc, and frequently short-term. Problematically, there is no resourcing for those scientists to meaningfully feedback that information to either the Ministry of Health or to Members of Parliament and government Ministers.

    Dietary guidelines can become locked in, and contradictions can fail to be chewed over. Without the capacity to address errors, information can become outdated and misleading. Government agencies and elected members – from local councils all the way up to government Ministers, are dependent on being informed by the Ministry of Health, when it comes to government policy.

    When it comes to complex health conditions, and alleviating and reversing metabolic or mental illness, based on different patient capacity – from socio-economic, to cultural, to social, and taking into account capacity for change, what is sound, evidence-based information and what is misinformation?

    In the impasse, who can we trust?

    Published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
    For reprints, please set the canonical link back to the original Brownstone Institute Article and Author.

    Author

    J.R. Bruning is a consultant sociologist (B.Bus.Agribusiness; MA Sociology) based in New Zealand. Her work explores governance cultures, policy and the production of scientific and technical knowledge. Her Master’s thesis explored the ways science policy creates barriers to funding, stymying scientists’ efforts to explore upstream drivers of harm. Bruning is a trustee of Physicians & Scientists for Global Responsibility (PSGR.org.nz). Papers and writing can be found at TalkingRisk.NZ and at JRBruning.Substack.com and at Talking Risk on Rumble.

    View all posts
    Your financial backing of Brownstone Institute goes to support writers, lawyers, scientists, economists, and other people of courage who have been professionally purged and displaced during the upheaval of our times. You can help get the truth out through their ongoing work.

    https://brownstone.org/articles/the-silent-shame-of-health-institutions/
    The Silent Shame of Health Institutions J.R. Bruning For how much longer will health policy ignore multimorbidity, that looming, giant elephant in the room, that propagates and amplifies suffering? For how much longer will the ‘trend’ of increasing diagnoses of multiple health conditions, at younger and younger ages be rendered down by government agencies to better and more efficient services, screening modalities, and drug choices? Multimorbidity, the presence of many chronic conditions, is the silent shame of health policy. All too often chronic conditions overlap and accumulate. From cancer, to diabetes, to digestive system diseases, to high blood pressure, to skin conditions in cascades of suffering. Heartbreakingly, these conditions commonly overlap with mental illnesses or disorders. It’s increasingly common for people to be diagnosed with multiple mental conditions, such as having anxiety and depression, or anxiety and schizophrenia. Calls for equity tend to revolve around medical treatment, even as absurdities and injustices accrue. Multimorbidity occurs a decade earlier in socioeconomically deprived communities. Doctors are diagnosing multimorbidity at younger and younger ages. Treatment regimens for people with multiple conditions necessarily entail a polypharmacy approach – the prescribing of multiple medications. One condition may require multiple medications. Thus, with multimorbidity comes increased risk of adverse outcomes and polyiatrogenesis – ‘medical harm caused by medical treatments on multiple fronts simultaneously and in conjunction with one another.’ Side effects, whether short-term or patients’ concerns about long-term harm, are the main reason for non-adherence to prescribed medications. So ‘equity’ which only implies drug treatment doesn’t involve equity at all. Poor diets may be foundational to the Western world’s health crisis. But are governments considering this? The antinomies are piling up. We are amid a global epidemic of metabolic syndrome. Insulin resistance, obesity, elevated triglyceride levels and low levels of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol, and elevated blood pressure haunt the people queuing up to see doctors. Research, from individual cases to clinical trials, consistently show that diets containing high levels of ultra-processed foods and carbohydrates amplify inflammation, oxidative stress, and insulin resistance. What researchers and scientists are also identifying, at the cellular level, in clinical and medical practice, and at the global level – is that insulin resistance, inflammation, oxidative stress, and nutrient deficiencies from poor diets not only drive metabolic illness, but mental illnesses, compounding suffering. There is also ample evidence that the metabolic and mental health epidemic that is driving years lost due to disease, reducing productivity, and creating mayhem in personal lives – may be preventable and reversible. Doctors generally recognise that poor diets are a problem. Ultra-processed foods are strongly associated with adult and childhood ill health. Ultra-processed foods are ‘formulations of ingredients, mostly of exclusive industrial use, typically created by series of industrial techniques and processes (hence ‘ultra-processed’).’ In the USA young people under age 19 consume on average 67% of their diet, while adults consume around 60% of their diet in ultra-processed food. Ultra-processed food contributes 60% of UK children’s calories; 42% of Australian children’s calories and over half the dietary calories for children and adolescents in Canada. In New Zealand in 2009-2010, ultra-processed foods contributed to the 45% (12 months), 42% (24 months), and 51% (60 months) of energy intake to the diets of children. All too frequently, doctors are diagnosing both metabolic and mental illnesses. What may be predictable is that a person is likely to develop insulin resistance, inflammation, oxidative stress, and nutrient deficiencies from chronic exposure to ultra-processed food. How this will manifest in a disease or syndrome condition is reflective of a human equivalent of quantum entanglement. Cascades, feedback loops, and other interdependencies often leave doctors and patients bouncing from one condition to another, and managing medicine side effects and drug-drug relationships as they go. In New Zealand it is more common to have multiple conditions than a single condition. The costs of having two NCDs simultaneously is typically superadditive and ‘more so for younger adults.’ This information is outside the ‘work programme’ of the top echelons in the Ministry of Health: Official Information Act (OIA) requests confirm that the Ministries’ Directors General who are responsible for setting policy and long-term strategy aren’t considering these issues. The problem of multimorbidity and the overlapping, entangled relationship with ultra-processed food is outside of the scope of the work programme of the top directorates in our health agency. New Zealand’s Ministry of Health’s top deputy directors general might be earning a quarter of a million dollars each, but they are ignorant of the relationship of dietary nutrition and mental health. Nor are they seemingly aware of the extent of multimorbidity and the overlap between metabolic and mental illnesses. Neither the Public Health Agency Deputy Director-General – Dr Andrew Old, nor the Deputy Director-General Evidence, Research and Innovation, Dean Rutherford, nor the Deputy Director-General of Strategy Policy and Legislation, Maree Roberts, nor the Clinical, Community and Mental Health Deputy Director-General Robyn Shearer have been briefed on these relationships. If they’re not being briefed, policy won’t be developed to address dietary nutrition. Diet will be lower-order. The OIA request revealed that New Zealand’s Ministry of Health ‘does not widely use the metabolic syndrome classification.’ When I asked ‘How do you classify, or what term do you use to classify the cluster of symptoms characterised by central obesity, dyslipidemia, hypertension, and insulin resistance?’, they responded: ‘The conditions referred to are considered either on their own or as part of a broader cardiovascular disease risk calculation.’ This is interesting. What if governments should be calculating insulin resistance first, in order to then calculate a broader cardiovascular risk? What if insulin resistance, inflammation, and oxidative stress are appearing at younger and younger ages, and ultra-processed food is the major driver? Pre-diabetes and Type 2 diabetes are driven by too much blood glucose. Type 1 diabetics can’t make insulin, while Type 2 diabetics can’t make enough to compensate for their dietary intake of carbohydrates. One of insulin’s (many) jobs is to tuck away that blood glucose into cells (as fat) but when there are too many dietary carbohydrates pumping up blood glucose, the body can’t keep up. New Zealand practitioners use the HbA1c blood test, which measures the average blood glucose level over the past 2-3 months. In New Zealand, doctors diagnose pre-diabetes if HbA1c levels are 41-49 nmol/mol, and diabetes at levels of 50 nmol/mol and above. Type 2 diabetes management guidelines recommend that sugar intake should be reduced, while people should aim for consistent carbohydrates across the day. The New Zealand government does not recommend paleo or low-carbohydrate diets. If you have diabetes you are twice as likely to have heart disease or a stroke, and at a younger age. Prediabetes, which apparently 20% of Kiwis have, is also high-risk due to, as the Ministry of Health states: ‘increased risk of macrovascular complications and early death.’ The question might become – should we be looking at insulin levels, to more sensitively gauge risk at an early stage? Without more sensitive screens at younger ages these opportunities to repivot to avoid chronic disease are likely to be missed. Currently, Ministry of Health policies are unlikely to justify the funding of tests for insulin resistance by using three simple blood tests: fasting insulin, fasting lipids (cholesterol and triglycerides), and fasting glucose – to estimate where children, young people, and adults stand on the insulin resistance spectrum when other diagnoses pop up. Yet insulin plays a powerful role in brain health. Insulin supports neurotransmitter function and brain energy, directly impacting mood and behaviours. Insulin resistance might arrive before mental illness. Harvard-based psychiatrist Chris Palmer recounts in the book Brain Energy, a large 15,000-participant study of young people from age 0-24: ‘Children who had persistently high insulin levels (a sign of insulin resistance) beginning at age nine were five times more likely to be at risk for psychosis, meaning they were showing at least some worrisome signs, and they were three times for likely to already be diagnosed with bipolar disorder or schizophrenia by the time they turned twenty-four. This study clearly demonstrated that insulin resistance comes first, then psychosis.’ Psychiatrist Georgia Ede suggests that high blood glucose and high insulin levels act like a ‘deadly one-two punch’ for the brain, triggering waves of inflammation and oxidative stress. The blood-brain barrier becomes increasingly resistant to chronic high insulin levels. Even though the body might have higher blood insulin, the same may not be true for the brain. As Ede maintains, ‘cells deprived of adequate insulin ‘sputter and struggle to maintain normal operations.’ Looking at the relationship between brain health and high blood glucose and high insulin simply might not be on the programme for strategists looking at long-term planning. Nor are Directors General in a position to assess the role of food addiction. Ultra-processed food has addictive qualities designed into the product formulations. Food addiction is increasingly recognised as pervasive and difficult to manage as any substance addiction. But how many children and young people have insulin resistance and are showing markers for inflammation and oxidative stress – in the body and in the brain? To what extent do young people have both insulin resistance and depression resistance or ADHD or bipolar disorder? This kind of thinking is completely outside the work programme. But insulin levels, inflammation, and oxidative stress may not only be driving chronic illness – but driving the global mental health tsunami. Metabolic disorders are involved in complex pathways and feedback loops across body systems, and doctors learn this at medical school. Patterns and relationships between hormones, the brain, the gastrointestinal system, kidneys, and liver; as well as problems with joints and bone health, autoimmunity, nerves, and sensory conditions evolve from and revolve around metabolic health. Nutrition and diet are downplayed in medical school. What doctors don’t learn so much – the cognitive dissonance that they must accept throughout their training – is that metabolic health is commonly (except for some instances) shaped by the quality of dietary nutrition. The aetiology of a given condition can be very different, while the evidence that common chronic and mental illnesses are accompanied by oxidative stress, inflammation, and insulin resistance are primarily driven by diet – is growing stronger and stronger. But without recognising the overlapping relationships, policy to support healthy diets will remain limp. What we witness are notions of equity that support pharmaceutical delivery – not health delivery. What also inevitably happens is that ‘equity’ focuses on medical treatment. When the Ministry of Health prefers to atomise the different conditions or associate them with heart disease – they become single conditions to treat with single drugs. They’re lots of small problems, not one big problem, and insulin resistance is downplayed. But just as insulin resistance, inflammation, and oxidative stress send cascading impacts across body systems, systemic ignorance sends cascading effects across government departments tasked with ‘improving, promoting, and protecting health.’ It’s an injustice. The literature solidly points to lower socio-economic status driving much poorer diets and increased exposures to ultra-processed food, but the treatments exclusively involve drugs and therapy. Briefings to Incoming Ministers with the election of new Governments show how ignorance cascades across responsible authorities. Health New Zealand, Te Whatu Ora’s November 2023 Briefing to the new government outlined the agency’s obligations. However, the ‘health’ targets are medical, and the agency’s focus is on infrastructure, staff, and servicing. The promotion of health, and health equity, which can only be addressed by addressing the determinants of health, is not addressed. The Mฤori Health Authority and Health New Zealand Joint Briefing to the Incoming Minister for Mental Health does not address the role of diet and nutrition as a driver of mental illness and disorder in New Zealand. The issue of multimorbidity, the related problem of commensurate metabolic illness, and diet as a driver is outside scope. When the Briefing states that it is important to address the ‘social, cultural, environmental and economic determinants of mental health,’ without any sound policy footing, real movement to address diet will not happen, or will only happen ad hoc. The Mental Health and Wellbeing Commission, Te Hiringa Mahara’s November 2023 Briefing to Incoming Ministers that went to the Ministers for Health and Mental Health might use the term ‘well-being’ over 120 times – but was silent on the related and overlapping drivers of mental illness which include metabolic or multimorbidity, nutrition, or diet. Five years earlier, He Ara Ora, New Zealand’s 2018 Mental Health and Addiction enquiry had recognised that tฤngata whaiora, people seeking wellness, or service users, also tend to have multiple health conditions. The enquiry recommended that a whole of government approach to well-being, prevention, and social determinants was required. Vague nods were made to diet and nutrition, but this was not sufficiently emphasised as to be a priority. He Ara Ora was followed by 2020 Long-term pathway to mental well-being viewed nutrition as being one of a range of factors. No policy framework strategically prioritised diet, nutrition, and healthy food. No governmental obligation or commitment was built into policy to improve access to healthy food or nutrition education. Understanding the science, the relationships, and the drivers of the global epidemic, is ‘outside the work programmes’ of New Zealand’s Ministry of Health and outside the scope of all the related authorities. There is an extraordinary amount of data in the scientific literature, so many case studies, cohort studies, and clinical trials. Popular books are being written, however government agencies remain ignorant. In the meantime, doctors must deal with the suffering in front of them without an adequate toolkit. Doctors and pharmacists are faced with a Hobson’s choice of managing multiple chronic conditions and complex drug cocktails, in patients at younger and younger ages. Ultimately, they are treating a patient whom they recognise will only become sicker, cost the health system more, and suffer more. Currently there is little support for New Zealand medical doctors (known as general practitioners, or GPs) in changing practices and recommendations to support non-pharmaceutical drug treatment approaches. Their medical education does not equip them to recognise the extent to which multiple co-existing conditions may be alleviated or reversed. Doctors are paid to prescribe, to inject, and to screen, not to ameliorate or reverse disease and lessen prescribing. The prescribing of nutrients is discouraged and as doctors do not have nutritional training, they hesitate to prescribe nutrients. Many do not want to risk going outside treatment guidelines. Recent surges in protocols and guidelines for medical doctors reduce flexibility and narrow treatment choices for doctors. If they were to be reported to the Medical Council of New Zealand, they would risk losing their medical license. They would then be unable to practice. Inevitably, without Ministry of Health leadership, medical doctors in New Zealand are unlikely to voluntarily prescribe non-drug modalities such as nutritional options to any meaningful extent, for fear of being reported. Yet some doctors are proactive, such as Dr Glen Davies in Taupo, New Zealand. Some doctors are in a better ‘place’ to work to alleviate and reverse long-term conditions. They may be later in their career, with 10-20 years of research into metabolism, dietary nutrition, and patient care, and motivated to guide a patient through a personal care regime which might alleviate or reverse a patient’s suffering. Barriers include resourcing. Doctors aren’t paid for reversing disease and taking patients off medications. Doctors witness daily the hopelessness felt by their patients in dealing with chronic conditions in their short 15-minute consultations, and the vigilance required for dealing with adverse drug effects. Drug non-compliance is associated with adverse effects suffered by patients. Yet without wrap-around support changing treatments, even if it has potential to alleviate multiple conditions, to reduce symptoms, lower prescribing and therefore lessen side effects, is just too uncertain. They saw what happened to disobedient doctors during Covid-19. Given such context, what are we to do? Have open public discussions about doctor-patient relationships and trust. Inform and overlay such conversations by drawing attention to the foundational Hippocratic Oath made by doctors, to first do no harm. Questions can be asked. If patients were to understand that diet may be an underlying driver of multiple conditions, and a change in diet and improvement in micronutrient status might alleviate suffering – would patients be more likely to change? Economically, if wrap-around services were provided in clinics to support dietary change, would less harm occur to patients from worsening conditions that accompany many diseases (such as Type 2 diabetes) and the ever-present problem of drug side-effects? Would education and wrap-around services in early childhood and youth delay or prevent the onset of multimorbid diagnoses? Is it more ethical to give young people a choice of treatment? Could doctors prescribe dietary changes and multinutrients and support change with wrap-around support when children and young people are first diagnosed with a mental health condition – from the clinic, to school, to after school? If that doesn’t work, then prescribe pharmaceutical drugs. Should children and young people be educated to appreciate the extent to which their consumption of ultra-processed food likely drives their metabolic and mental health conditions? Not just in a blithe ‘eat healthy’ fashion that patently avoids discussing addiction. Through deeper policy mechanisms, including cooking classes and nutritional biology by the implementation of nourishing, low-carbohydrate cooked school lunches. With officials uninformed, it’s easy to see why funding for Green Prescriptions that would support dietary changes have sputtered out. It’s easy to understand why neither the Ministry of Health nor Pharmac have proactively sourced multi-nutrient treatments that improve resilience to stress and trauma for low-income young people. Why there’s no discussion on a lower side-effect risk for multinutrient treatments. Why are there no policies in the education curriculum diving into the relationship between ultra-processed food and mental and physical health? It’s not in the work programme. There’s another surfacing dilemma. Currently, if doctors tell their patients that there is very good evidence that their disease or syndrome could be reversed, and this information is not held as factual information by New Zealand’s Ministry of Health – do doctors risk being accused of spreading misinformation? Government agencies have pivoted in the past 5 years to focus intensively on the problem of dis- and misinformation. New Zealand’s disinformation project states that Disinformation is false or modified information knowingly and deliberately shared to cause harm or achieve a broader aim. Misinformation is information that is false or misleading, though not created or shared with the direct intention of causing harm. Unfortunately, as we see, there is no division inside the Ministry of Health that reviews the latest evidence in the scientific literature, to ensure that policy decisions correctly reflect the latest evidence. There is no scientific agency outside the Ministry of Health that has flexibility and the capacity to undertake autonomous, long-term monitoring and research in nutrition, diet, and health. There is no independent, autonomous, public health research facility with sufficient long-term funding to translate dietary and nutritional evidence into policy, particularly if it contradicted current policy positions. Despite excellent research being undertaken, it is highly controlled, ad hoc, and frequently short-term. Problematically, there is no resourcing for those scientists to meaningfully feedback that information to either the Ministry of Health or to Members of Parliament and government Ministers. Dietary guidelines can become locked in, and contradictions can fail to be chewed over. Without the capacity to address errors, information can become outdated and misleading. Government agencies and elected members – from local councils all the way up to government Ministers, are dependent on being informed by the Ministry of Health, when it comes to government policy. When it comes to complex health conditions, and alleviating and reversing metabolic or mental illness, based on different patient capacity – from socio-economic, to cultural, to social, and taking into account capacity for change, what is sound, evidence-based information and what is misinformation? In the impasse, who can we trust? Published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License For reprints, please set the canonical link back to the original Brownstone Institute Article and Author. Author J.R. Bruning is a consultant sociologist (B.Bus.Agribusiness; MA Sociology) based in New Zealand. Her work explores governance cultures, policy and the production of scientific and technical knowledge. Her Master’s thesis explored the ways science policy creates barriers to funding, stymying scientists’ efforts to explore upstream drivers of harm. Bruning is a trustee of Physicians & Scientists for Global Responsibility (PSGR.org.nz). Papers and writing can be found at TalkingRisk.NZ and at JRBruning.Substack.com and at Talking Risk on Rumble. View all posts Your financial backing of Brownstone Institute goes to support writers, lawyers, scientists, economists, and other people of courage who have been professionally purged and displaced during the upheaval of our times. You can help get the truth out through their ongoing work. https://brownstone.org/articles/the-silent-shame-of-health-institutions/
    BROWNSTONE.ORG
    The Silent Shame of Health Institutions โ‹† Brownstone Institute
    There is no scientific agency outside the Ministry of Health that has flexibility and the capacity to undertake autonomous, long-term monitoring and research in nutrition, diet and health.
    0 Comments 0 Shares 33452 Views
  • Hi mate, I have been part of Green Chain community and I have earned GREEN coin & I want to share this great opportunity to you.

    All Telegram users can now mine Green directly from their devices on Android or iOS!

    Please join my GREEN Chain network now and start earning!



    https://www.greenchain.app/invite/coprochain
    Hi mate, I have been part of Green Chain community and I have earned GREEN coin & I want to share this great opportunity to you. All Telegram users can now mine Green directly from their devices on Android or iOS! Please join my GREEN Chain network now and start earning! https://www.greenchain.app/invite/coprochain
    Green Chain - Revolutionizing Blockchain with Environmental Responsibility
    Green Chain is revolutionizing blockchain technology with eco-friendly solutions. Experience sustainable mining, low gas fees, and fast transactions today.
    1 Comments 0 Shares 1910 Views
  • Instantly receive $750 in your Cash App account.
    Join Cash App $750 Giveaway : https://tinyurl.com/bdc7kp2d

    Hey, everyone! I'm Mery Lee to announce cash app latest endeavor – the Cash App $750 Giveaway!
    We're here to spread joy and put some extra cash in your pockets.
    You have a chance to Win a Cash App gift card for free! You've received a $750 CASH APP new 2024 gift card.
    Do not miss it. It's a giveaway offer.

    Now, let's get down to the nitty-gritty. Participating in the Cash App $750 Giveaway is as easy as pie.
    All you need to do is follow these simple steps.
    1 Sign Up: click this link andJoin the Cash App revolution in seconds it's fast, easy, and secure.
    2 Complete Tasks: Discover exciting offers and complete tasks to earn real cash rewards.
    3 Redeem: Convert your earnings into a Cash App Gift Card and watch your financial dreams come true!
    Join Cash App $750 Giveaway : https://tinyurl.com/bdc7kp2d
    #Cashapp #Cashappblessing #Cashmoney #Cashappgiveaway #Giftcard #Giftcardgiveaway #freegiftcard #makemoney #Makemoneyonline #onlinemoney #digitalmoney #Makemoneyathome
    ๐Ÿ‘‰Instantly receive $750 in your Cash App account. Join Cash App $750 Giveaway : https://tinyurl.com/bdc7kp2d Hey, everyone! I'm Mery Lee to announce cash app latest endeavor – the Cash App $750 Giveaway! We're here to spread joy and put some extra cash in your pockets. You have a chance to Win a Cash App gift card for free! You've received a $750 CASH APP new 2024 gift card. Do not miss it. It's a giveaway offer. Now, let's get down to the nitty-gritty. Participating in the Cash App $750 Giveaway is as easy as pie. All you need to do is follow these simple steps.๐Ÿ‘‡๐Ÿ‘‡ 1 Sign Up: click this link andJoin the Cash App revolution in seconds it's fast, easy, and secure. 2 Complete Tasks: Discover exciting offers and complete tasks to earn real cash rewards. 3 Redeem: Convert your earnings into a Cash App Gift Card and watch your financial dreams come true! Join Cash App $750 Giveaway : https://tinyurl.com/bdc7kp2d #Cashapp #Cashappblessing #Cashmoney #Cashappgiveaway #Giftcard #Giftcardgiveaway #freegiftcard #makemoney #Makemoneyonline #onlinemoney #digitalmoney #Makemoneyathome
    0 Comments 0 Shares 5366 Views
  • Apply this job for Per day $10 USD earning
    Send your detils in this mail for earning
    Email:[email protected]
    Apply this job for Per day $10 USD earning Send your detils in this mail for earning Email:[email protected]
    1 Comments 0 Shares 1041 Views
  • TikTok Earning Hack Review | Ultimate Ticket to Extraordinary Income


    TikTok Earning Hack Review – This fantastic product includes Private Label Rights and offers incredible advantages…

    Access Premium Content for Your E-Books, Blogs, Articles, and Beyond. Brand it as Your Own and Retain 100% of the Profits. Complete Blown Ready-to-Market Sales Material for Reselling. Ready-made, High-Quality Promotional Material to Sell & Keep 100% Profit without Much Effort!

    Properly Researched & High-In-Demand, Hot Niche Aid in Revenue Generation Today. No Technical Expertise or Unique Skill is Required. Drive in Responsive Leads on Complete Auto-Pilot.

    TikTok Earning Hack Review – What can you do?

    You can bundle it with other products.

    You can offer it as a bonus to your existing product and make your customers happy.

    You can use it for other video products or webinars.

    You can distribute it to your affiliates for them to promote you.

    You can also create eBooks and create multiple eBooks out of them.

    You can retain paying members by adding this product to your paid membership site.

    You can rename, rebrand, or customize it and claim full authorship. Everything is up to you.

    TikTok Earning Hack Review|Ultimate Ticket to Extraordinary Income
    TikTok Earning Hack Review - This fantastic product includes Private Label Rights and offers incredible advantages...
    https://dilip-review.com/tiktok-earning-hack-review/
    TikTok Earning Hack Review | Ultimate Ticket to Extraordinary Income TikTok Earning Hack Review – This fantastic product includes Private Label Rights and offers incredible advantages… Access Premium Content for Your E-Books, Blogs, Articles, and Beyond. Brand it as Your Own and Retain 100% of the Profits. Complete Blown Ready-to-Market Sales Material for Reselling. Ready-made, High-Quality Promotional Material to Sell & Keep 100% Profit without Much Effort! Properly Researched & High-In-Demand, Hot Niche Aid in Revenue Generation Today. No Technical Expertise or Unique Skill is Required. Drive in Responsive Leads on Complete Auto-Pilot. TikTok Earning Hack Review – What can you do? ๐Ÿ‘Œ You can bundle it with other products. ๐Ÿ‘Œ You can offer it as a bonus to your existing product and make your customers happy. ๐Ÿ‘Œ You can use it for other video products or webinars. ๐Ÿ‘Œ You can distribute it to your affiliates for them to promote you. ๐Ÿ‘Œ You can also create eBooks and create multiple eBooks out of them. ๐Ÿ‘Œ You can retain paying members by adding this product to your paid membership site. ๐Ÿ‘Œ You can rename, rebrand, or customize it and claim full authorship. Everything is up to you. TikTok Earning Hack Review|Ultimate Ticket to Extraordinary Income TikTok Earning Hack Review - This fantastic product includes Private Label Rights and offers incredible advantages... https://dilip-review.com/tiktok-earning-hack-review/
    DILIP-REVIEW.COM
    TikTok Earning Hack Review|Ultimate Ticket to Extraordinary Income
    TikTok Earning Hack Review - This fantastic product includes Private Label Rights and offers incredible advantages...
    1 Comments 0 Shares 3831 Views
More Results